As a junior in 1963-64, Tiner scored 656 points (5th best in JU single-season history) and averaged 25.2 points per game to be named to both All-American teams as an honorable mention. A career 21.4 points per game scorer, Tiner’s career average trails only three other inductees to the Hall of Fame (Strickland, Gilmore, and Morgan). At the time of graduation for JU, Tiner was 2nd on the career rebounding list, having grabbed 720 boards for a 7.1 per game average.
In addition to his All-American honors, Tiner was selected to the All-Florida Intercollegiate Conference team four times, including three first-team honors. All this was from a man whose career was delayed after serving a 26-month stint in the U.S. Army.